Mayor Kirk Shares Feedback On the Good Harbor Beach Footbridge Poll and Plans On How They Plan To Proceed From Here

Hi Joey,

The verdict from the poll is in but it really isn’t as simple as saying, well 64% voted for the aluminum fix and 36% voted for the wooden fix so we’ll put up the aluminum span.  As with just about everything, it’s way more complicated than that.  If you would allow me to,

I’d like to share some of the feedback we’ve received and how we plan on proceeding from here.

In addition to the polling results, there have been many thoughtful email and Facebook messages and phone calls that have come through my office or DPW.  An artist sent a picture of the beautiful Milton Avery painting of a couple walking across the footbridge.  Another person sent a picture of what was thought to be the actual wooden bridge that washed away and into the marsh by Stop & Shop.  Turns out, that was the section of the bridge that washed away in 2006!!  This past winter it has moved into a position where it can be retrieved and DPW will remove it.

People sent links to other “synthetic” solutions, and links to other wooden bridge examples.  And of course, your display today was beautiful.  A lot of questions have come up as well, and I will do my best to answer them.

Cost is clearly a factor that is on people’s minds.  $65,000 seemed to be outrageous for the wooden fix.  That estimate is for an outsourced solution, i.e., not using our DPW.

The timetable seemed troubling to some people.  We were required to go through a Conservation Commission review, and that takes a number of weeks in addition we had to wait to get the estimate and plan for the fix before proceeding to ConCom.

The way we put the poll out there, it wasn’t clear if we were talking about temporary fixes or permanent fixes.  Basically, ConCom has said, “this is the last temporary fix (however we do it).”  The city is encouraged to come back with a permanent plan that addresses the resource area, takes into consideration the structural integrity of the rest of the bridge, and perhaps is redesigned to withstand the types of storms and tidal surges we are experiencing.  Neither choice in the poll addressed these issues.

Then the question of the Magnolia Pier came up.  This is one of those quirky things about how our waterways are governed.  The city has responsibility for the Good Harbor Footbridge, but the Harbormaster and the Waterways Board have responsibility for the Magnolia Pier!

And then of course, some people wanted the best of both worlds – New England charm and Yankee ingenuity which I take to mean a more cost effective solution that preserves the iconic character of the footbridge.

A couple of people suggested a “buy a plank” program where if you got married on the bridge or the beach, you could buy an engraved plank to help offset the cost of the repairs.  Sort of like a memorial bench or brick program.

So – here’s what it’s come down to.  DPW Director Mike Hale and I met today, and we’ve decided to use our DPW guys to do a wooden repair.   I have directed him to retask some of his staff, order the materials and start immediately.  While this will save the city about $60,000 it reduces the manpower that DPW can devote to all those other things citizens find important (which is why outsourcing was an attractive option).

We will formulate a Building Committee as required by the City Charter and pursue a permanent redesign.  The Committee can take the time to go through all ideas, and do this right.

Joey, thank you for allowing me to pose the poll to the GoodMorningGloucester readers.  Most importantly, I appreciate the spark of discussion and ideas that ensued.
Mayor Kirk

8 comments

  • Yay!! Good job, good decision, Good Harbor Bridge will be back—and all the art and photos in my house will still match the real thing! Thank you Mayor Kirk!

    Like

  • Why not ask for volunteers to help under the direction of DPW? Have you seen the Danvers Swamp Walk? All Volunteer. Same with the rail trail bridges, the rehab of the old B&M Ipswich River Bridge and spillway in Topsfield. All volunteers! Huge savings.

    Like

    • Yes, I agree with Pete above; what about volunteers
      to work under the direction of the DPW?
      And for those of us who are not physically able
      to volunteer, how about setting up some vehicle
      to fund this?
      I take the bus to Good Harbor Beach (no car) & I
      think those of us who use the bridge could pay
      some kind of toll throughout this summer, just to
      help defray the long-term costs.
      Just my 2 cents.

      Like

  • Thank you Mayor Kirk for making yet another good decision – Moving Gloucester forward

    Like

  • Good decision. I will help if volunteers are needed.

    Like

  • as I have stated adopt a bridge program.$20-100 dollars to own part of the bridge.this would not only bring pride to our city but tourism

    Like

  • thank you glos! as a summer visitor to my favorite beach:I loved THAT bridge;many pictures of it are in my home! i was so sad when i heard of the devastation you all suffered! I wish there was someway you could recupe $ from your loss! ???fund raisers;donations throughout the summere(i KNOW visitors would take note) i wish you success in what ever manner you” BRING BACK THE BRIDGE” May God Bless. sincerely’a vermont visitor

    Like

Leaving a comment rewards the author of this post- add to the discussion here-

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s